Episode Summary
Hosts
Graham Dunn, Jamie Rooney
Phil Craig, Declan Clark
Guest(s)
Release Date
29 June 2023
Duration
50 min
In this special season finale of By Far The Greatest Team, hosts Graham Dunn and Jamie Rooney close out Season 1 by looking back at every team, debate, and ranking that shaped their journey so far. With a full season of football history behind them — from Hereford United’s FA Cup miracle to Hamburg’s European exploits and Brazil 1970’s enduring dominance — the duo take stock of what they got right, what they might have misjudged, and which teams deserve promotion or relegation within their Greatness Index categories.
The discussion celebrates the diversity of teams covered — from world champions to cult heroes — and reflects on how context, culture, and memory shape football’s idea of greatness. Graham and Jamie revisit controversial rankings, reassess narratives, and even admit where emotion might have clouded logic. Along the way, they re-evaluate the All-Time Greats, True Greats, Touch of Greatness, Edge of Greatness, and Blinkered Greats tiers, bringing new perspective to the ongoing Greatness Index.
As the conversation unfolds, listeners get a behind-the-scenes look at how each episode evolved, how the categories were refined, and how storytelling became central to defining footballing legacy.
With the first season complete, the hosts take a moment to thank their growing community of listeners around the world and tease what’s coming next — new eras, new voices, and the same mission: to keep asking the question that started it all… What makes a team truly great?
Takeaways
Greatness is subjective — context matters as much as trophies.
Promotion and relegation keep historical debate alive.
The By Far The Greatest Team tiers evolved through conversation.
Teams like Hereford, Hamburg, and Brazil sparked the fiercest debate.
Storytelling is the heartbeat of football history.
Season 1 Finale: The Greatness Relegation Debate
As Season 1 draws to a close, By Far The Greatest Team revisits every side ranked so far — from Hereford United’s fairytale FA Cup triumph to Hamburg’s European brilliance and Brazil 1970’s world-beating artistry.
In this reflective finale, Graham Dunn and Jamie Rooney put their own Greatness Index to the test, deciding which teams deserve promotion, which must face relegation, and whether the categories themselves still hold up. What began as a simple ranking exercise now becomes a deeper exploration of how footballing greatness is defined — by trophies, by timing, or by the stories that live forever.
More than a season recap, this episode celebrates the spirit of debate, nostalgia, and shared obsession that fuel the podcast. It’s a fitting end to a season that spanned continents, eras, and emotions — and a promise that the journey to define greatness has only just begun.
Main Topics
Iconic Moments
Reviewing all Season 1 team rankings
Promotion and relegation within the Greatness Index tiers
Revisiting key debates (Hereford, Hamburg, Brazil 1970)
The role of storytelling in defining greatness
Looking ahead to Season 2
Re-evaluating Hereford’s “greatest giant-killing”
The Hamburg European Cup debate
Brazil 1970’s invincibility challenged
Graham proposes a new ranking category
“I think Hereford might be fractionally fortunate”
Final tier reshuffle before the season break
Notable Manager
Various
Notable Players
Various
Style of Play
Reflective Discussion, Tier Review, Historical Analysis, Contextual Re-Ranking, Football Legacy
As a season finale rather than a single-team focus, this episode mirrors the variety of footballing philosophies explored throughout Season 1. It jumps between tactical eras and cultural contrasts — from the fluid artistry of Brazil 1970’s 4-2-4 to the disciplined German precision of Hamburg’s late-1970s 4-3-3, and from the raw directness of Hereford’s 1972 FA Cup spirit to the bravery of wartime heroes like FC Start 1942.
The discussion itself reflects a “total football” of conversation — free-flowing, adaptive, and intelligent. Graham and Jamie approach each re-ranking like a manager adjusting tactics mid-match: balancing emotion with evidence, nostalgia with nuance. The tone captures the rhythm of the season — debates rising and falling like a match in extra time, punctuated by laughter, insight, and the occasional tactical disagreement.
This episode marks a full-circle moment — a reflection of every style, strategy, and story explored so far.
Related Content
If you liked this one, you’ll love these classic episodes. Keep the nostalgia going — explore more from the By Far The Greatest Team Football Podcast archive.
