Episode Summary
Hosts
Graham Dunn, Jamie Rooney
Jamie Wilson, Phil Craig, Declan Clark
Guest(s)
Release Date
26 December 2024
Duration
97 min
In this By Far The Greatest Team festive special — the Boxing Day Bonanza — hosts Graham Dunn and Jamie Rooney are joined by regulars Jamie “South Coast” Wilson, Declan Clark, and Phil Craig for a Christmas challenge: each pick a team, argue its greatness in under ten minutes, and let the others decide if the ranking holds up.
In one of the most entertaining turns, Phil Craig chooses Arsenal 1939 — a side frozen in time on the eve of World War II, and immortalised in the cult football film The Arsenal Stadium Mystery. As football’s first cinematic crossover, it featured Arsenal’s real players performing as themselves, playing the “mystery opponents” in a whodunit thriller filmed just months before Britain declared war.
Phil dives into how Arsenal, then managed by George Allison, were both sporting and cultural icons — reigning champions, innovators in tactics and professionalism, and ambassadors for a game about to be interrupted by global conflict. The conversation blends film trivia, football heritage, and absurd humour, as the hosts unpack what it meant for a football team to become literal movie stars in 1939 London.
It’s a nostalgic mix of celluloid and sport, proving that sometimes football greatness isn’t just about what happens on the pitch — it’s about the stories that survive when the lights go down.
Takeaways
Hearts’ 2005–06 challenge to Scotland’s football elite
Tranmere’s golden 1990s run under John King
Arsenal 1939 and The Arsenal Stadium Mystery film connection
San Marino’s surprising 2024 unbeaten streak
Oxford United’s 1986 League Cup triumph and legacy
Arsenal 1939: The Mystery of Football’s First Movie Stars
In 1939, Arsenal Football Club stood at the height of its powers — reigning champions, innovators of modern tactics, and icons of professionalism. But that year, they did something no team had ever done before: they went to the movies.
The Arsenal Stadium Mystery wasn’t just a novelty — it was the first feature film to star real footballers as themselves. Shot inside Highbury’s elegant Art Deco stands, it turned Arsenal into national celebrities and captured a world on the brink of war.
Managed by George Allison, Arsenal played the “Mystery Team” in the film’s fictional murder plot — a mix of suspense, humour, and footballing spectacle. Yet behind the charm was a poignant truth: just months later, many of these same players would be serving in uniform as the Second World War halted the Football League.
Arsenal 1939 became a symbol of football’s lost innocence — the last great pre-war team, immortalised in celluloid. Their W-M formation, tactical mastery, and stars like Ted Drake and Cliff Bastin made them as formidable on screen as on grass.
More than 80 years on, The Arsenal Stadium Mystery remains a time capsule — not just of a team, but of an era when football and film briefly collided to tell a story of fame, fate, and fleeting glory.
Main Topics
Iconic Moments
The Arsenal Stadium Mystery and football’s first film crossover
Arsenal’s pre-war dominance under George Allison
How 1939 symbolised the end of an era before WWII
The fusion of football, media, and pop culture
The surreal link between fiction, fame, and football legacy
Arsenal’s players appearing in The Arsenal Stadium Mystery (1939)
Filming at Highbury’s famous Art Deco stands
Britain declaring war just months after the film’s release
Arsenal’s pre-war First Division dominance (1930–38)
The preservation of the film as football’s first cinematic record
Notable Manager
George Allison
Notable Players
Eddie Hapgood, Cliff Bastin, Ted Drake, George Swindin, Wilf Copping, Bernard Joy, Leslie Compton, Alf Kirchen, Bryn Jones
Style of Play
W-M Formation, Structured, Counter-Attacking, Organised, Disciplined, Professional
By 1939, Arsenal were the masters of tactical modernity in English football. Building on the foundation laid by Herbert Chapman, George Allison had refined the W-M formation, a tactical innovation that balanced defence and attack through structured spacing and disciplined passing.
Arsenal’s play combined organisation with sharp counter-attacking — an early version of controlled transition football. Players like Eddie Hapgood and Wilf Copping gave the side steel and precision at the back, while Cliff Bastin and Ted Drake provided creativity and goals up front.
Their style was pragmatic yet elegant, reflecting Arsenal’s reputation as football’s first true “institutional club”: professional in preparation, reserved in image, and fiercely consistent. Matches at Highbury became as much theatre as sport — and when the film cameras rolled for The Arsenal Stadium Mystery, that theatre found a literal stage.
It was a team defined not just by tactics, but by timing — the final flourish of pre-war English football, frozen forever on black and white film.
Related Content
If you liked this one, you’ll love these classic episodes. Keep the nostalgia going — explore more from the By Far The Greatest Team Football Podcast archive.
